Most Booked Players 24/25: Who Collects Cards Across the Leagues
Statteo Desk ·
Player booking markets live and die on repeat offenders. Some players just referee themselves into trouble every week — the fouls, the back-chat, the tactical yellows to stop a counter — and if you're going to poke around card markets, the first thing worth doing is knowing who those players actually are. So here's who topped the charts across the Premier League, Championship and Scottish Premiership last season, with the appearance counts alongside, because a raw yellow-card total means very little without knowing how many games it took to get there.
In the Premier League, three players finished on 12 yellows: Everton's James Garner (38 apps), Wolves' André (35 apps) and Wolves' Yerson Mosquera (27 apps). That last one is the eye-catcher. Mosquera picked up the same 12 cards as Garner but did it in 11 fewer appearances — that's a booking roughly every other game he played. Wolves having two men on 12 tells its own story about the sort of season they had defensively.
Just behind them on 11 were Casemiro at Manchester United (34 apps) and Moisés Caicedo at Chelsea (33 apps), both of them holding-midfield types whose job description more or less guarantees a steady flow of tactical fouls. And then there's Cristian Romero at Spurs on 10 yellows — but crucially in just 23 appearances. On a per-game basis that's the busiest rate of anyone in the Premier League list here, which is exactly what you'd expect from Romero if you've watched him for five minutes.
Drop into the Championship and the totals climb, which is partly a function of more league games to play. Amadou Mbengue (QPR), Flynn Downes (Southampton) and Matt Crooks (Hull City) all racked up 13 yellows. But the appearance columns split them: Mbengue and Downes did it across 41 and 39 games respectively, while Crooks got there in just 34. Fewer games, same number of cards — Crooks is the one collecting them at the fastest clip of that trio.
The rest of the Championship names are worth filing away too. Nestory Irankunda at Watford (12 in 39) is notable simply because he's an attacker rather than a midfield destroyer, which is less common on a list like this. Callum Styles at West Brom hit 12 but across a full-throttle 45 appearances, and Lewie Coyle at Hull managed 12 in 42. High totals, but spread thin — their per-game booking rates are among the calmest here despite the big raw numbers.
Up in Scotland, Alexandros Gogić (St Mirren) and Brad Spencer (Falkirk) both landed on 13 yellows, from 35 and 38 appearances. Those are healthy rates, though the usual caveat applies harder here than anywhere: a different league means different refereeing standards and a different tempo, so don't assume a Scottish Premiership card count maps neatly onto anything you're used to reading in England.
A few things to keep in your head before any of this is useful. Appearances matter as much as the total — 12 in 27 (Mosquera) and 12 in 45 (Styles) are two completely different players from a booking point of view, even though the headline number is identical. Small samples cut the other way too: Romero's 23 games is a shorter run to draw firm conclusions from than a player who's clocked 40-plus. And none of these figures tell you anything about opponent, referee, or whether a player's role changes with a new manager.
The honest takeaway is a simple one. This is a starting point, not a verdict. Knowing that Mosquera, Romero and Crooks were collecting cards fastest relative to their minutes is genuinely useful context — but it's context to build on with fixtures, referees and team news, not a shortcut to a decision. The numbers describe what happened last season. What you do with them is your call.
Statteo — tips that show their working
18+ · Patterns, not tips · begambleaware.org